Click here for full submission

Solicitors representing the Manly Rugby Union Club have today lodged a comprehensive submission with the Northern Beaches Council outlining its position on the proposed carpark development at Manly Oval. The submission is critical of the development application which they say has misrepresented the arrangements between the former Manly Council and the Club over its relocation to Keirle Park and the prospects of the Club’s return to Manly Oval. The submission criticises the DA for not detailing the full impact of the proposed reduction of the Sydney Road boundary to Manly Oval.

Club Vice President, Anthony Bergelin, who has signed off on the submission has emphasised that the Club has been trying to reach a binding agreement with the Council over its relocation to Keirle Park since June 2011, when the development was first mooted.

He said: “Whilst more recently we have been engaging with the former Council no agreement has been reached or allocation of funds made and we are very concerned, since the Council merger for the future of our club and for the locals, both supporters and players, who use and enjoy the ground.”
Bergelin went on to say:

“The Environmental Impact Statement attached with the DA does not adequately deal with the impact of the reduction in boundary size of the ground. It is a deal breaker for the Marlins because it may prevent the Club from competing in the Shute Shield from Manly Oval.”

The proposal is also critical of the relocation of the Merrett Memorial Gates to a site adjacent to the bike entrance to the carpark.
Bergelin commented: “The historical significance of the Merrett Gates should not be compromised by such an imposing development and the Applicants need to demonstrate that they are sensitive to that significance.”

The MRFC’s submission has recommended a number of conditions that need to be included into the development application before it should be considered.


Home game vs Parramatta Two Blues, 3pm, Sat 11th June, Manly Oval

After the wild and wet weekend the MMMs now have a manic schedule: Two Blues tomorrow, Easts on Tues evening (7.45pm) and Souths next weekend – all games at Manly Oval. Lying 8th on the table these are important games and against strong opposition.

“It is surprising how quickly you can get rusty,” said MMMs coach Damien Cummins. “But we’ve had a good two weeks training and the guys are really upbeat.”

Half back Matt Lucas is back from the Waratahs during the international window and has trained with the team this week. Hooker James Hilterbrand is off in the US with the Eagles for three tests. Vance Elliot comes in at hooker.

The Two Blues have beaten Eastwood and had close losses to Uni and Souths. “They have a new coach and former Wallaby defence coach, John Muggleton, has been helping out. They have the biggest pack in the Shute Shield and will play to their strengths through the scrum and mauls,” said Damien.

On some of the recent losses, Damien commented: “We’ve worked hard on defence and decision making. We have a good leadership group and Matt will also help in getting us organised.”

It is worth remembering that whilst the MMMs beat Parramatta 59-36 in Round 2, those 36 points were let in. The big D will be needed.

Captain Kotoni is back

“I was quite nervous returning,” said Kotoni Ale, No7 and MMMs captain about coming onto the field off the bench against the Rats after a year rehabilitating from an ankle injury sustained in the same game last season. “Each game I grow in confidence and am picking up the pace.

“I am just enjoying it and forget about the injury when I am stuck in the action.”

Kotoni has also taken on the captaincy again. “I am privileged and honoured to be captaining again. James (Hilterbrand) and Sam (Lane) have done a great job and we have a good leadership group.”


Captain Kotoni taking teh ball up - photo: Adam MacDonald

Kotoni came through St Augustine’s College and started playing grade at Manly in 2011, He is a powerful No 7, tough at the breakdown and in defence.

He keeps himself busy as a PE teacher at St Augustine’s and rugby coach of the Vikings. “It is a combined under 16 team from the Harlequins, Seaforth Raiders and Manly Roos clubs. They train before first grade on Thursday evenings and then play on Sundays,” he explained. “They are going well despite a not so good pre-season.”

“There are some good players and it would be great to see them come up through the Marlins ranks.”

Hopefully we will see some Kotonis coming through the ranks from this rugby nursery!

Home game vs Easts, 3pm, Sat 4th June, Manly Oval

Languishing 8th on the table, the Marlin Army is starting to ask what’s happening? The story so far this season has been about having the upper hand only to let teams back in during the last ten or fifteen minutes. Uni, Eastwood, Easts, Norths (40-36 last weekend at Manly Oval) have all taken games off the MMMs when we’ve been in a leading position going into the last quarter.

“It is not panic stations,” said MMMs No 7 and captain, Kotoni Ale. “It is tight on the table with 6, 7 and 8 all on the same points and not far behind the top of the table. We are working hard for wins.

“We have been impacted by injuries and the arrival of new players and so we keep working hard on our combinations and structure.”

Kotoni was dismissive of the pack potentially not being fit enough but did acknowledge that defensive structures have not been good enough when needed most.

“Defence is about attitude and we need the attitude to be right,” explained Kotoni. Holes seem to appear on counter attack from kicks. “Yeah, we need to get the defensive line aligned and improve the link between forwards and backs.”

“We have been guilty of giving away crucial penalties and not using the ball when we’ve been in good positions. The positive though is that we have been playing some good footy. We just need to stop those periods where we seem to switch off,” continued Kotoni. When it works the team looks good, often racking up a good score early on. When this is delivered over the full 80 mins, the MMMs will be up there with the best teams in the comp.

“We took the loss (against Norths) hard both individually and as a team especially as it was a big day for the club with Ladies Day,” said Kotoni.

It looks like it will be stuff it up the jumper conditions with rain and wind predicted. “It will be a forward dominated game in wet weather. It will be tight but we have prepared well and the boys are looking for a big game.”

Easts will no doubt be looking for another four grade sweep from a few weeks ago but look out for the injured Marlin.